Fear of a cooling labour market is trapping New Zealand workers in a cycle of “job hugging”, staying in roles they would prefer to leave because switching jobs feels risky.
But those concerns are having a potentially negative effect on normal levels of transition and mobility, according to the Employment Hero Annual Jobs Report 2026.
Drawing on 13 months of Employment Hero platform data across more than 2,300 New Zealand organisations and 105,000 employees, alongside a Pureprofile survey of 804 employed Kiwis, the report reveals a stagnant labour market where hiring has held steady, but pay growth has stalled.
Median year-on-year wage growth across New Zealand SMEs dropped to 1.1 per cent in October 2026, down sharply from 2.8 per cent a year earlier, and even dipped into negative wage growth territory of -0.3 per cent in July. While 71 per cent of surveyed workers received a pay rise in the last 12 months, 58 per cent say that wage increases have failed to keep pace with the rising cost of living.
With Stats NZ reporting unemployment at 5.7 per cent and underutilisation rising to 13.8 per cent, workers are trading ambition for a sense of safety. But should the “job hugging” trend continue as a result of uncertainty, experts fear workers may pay a long term price.
The Myriad Costs of Job Hugging
Stability is coming before ambition
Up to 68 per cent of surveyed workers say they have stayed in a job they wanted to leave because moving felt too risky or difficult, while 63 per cent say the cost of living has forced them to prioritise job security over career ambition.
The comfort deficit
Meanwhile, half of employed New Zealanders earn less than the income they say they need simply to feel financially comfortable. For those falling short, the median gap is $37,500 a year. Even among full-time workers who are earning a median of $86,700 against a $100,400 comfort target, the typical shortfall sits at $13,700.
Loyalty penalties
More than 34 per cent believe employees who stay loyal to their employer end up worse off financially, compared to just 22 per cent who believe loyalty pays off. Meanwhile, 13 per cent say waiting periods for leave entitlements are actively stopping them from changing jobs a friction point expected to persist until the Employment Leave Act takes effect in 2028.
Side hustles on the rise
A small cohort of Kiwis are getting creative outside of work to cover the rising cost of living. As grocery pressures (63 per cent), fuel and transport costs (51 per cent), and energy bills (50 per cent) bite, 12 per cent of Kiwi workers took on a second job or freelance work over the past year to bridge the gap.
Independent Business Futurist & AI Strategist Kim Seeling Smith warns that staying put in the hopes of finding comfort carries hidden career risks, particularly as artificial intelligence reshapes workplaces.
“In an uncertain market, staying put makes sense on paper. The trouble is that the job people are holding on to is changing underneath them. AI is already absorbing routine administrative work and repeatable tasks,” she says.
“A role can stay on the books while the work inside it changes completely. Over the next few years, the bigger risk for many workers is staying in a role that stops building the skills they’ll need next.”
Employment Hero Global Insight Lead Lisa Cowie adds that the lack of worker movement in New Zealand is removing the traditional triggers for employers and business owners to offer competitive raises.
“Pay in New Zealand has stalled while hiring has held up. When unemployment rises and only half of workers feel confident they could land a new job within three months, staying put starts to look like the safest option.
“The catch is that when fewer people move, employers have less reason to pay up to keep the talent they have or attract new staff. Until businesses start treating pay and clear career progression as tools to retain their existing teams and until workers feel confident enough to test their market value pay growth is likely to stay subdued.”








